Can AI Trace a Cooling-Control Circuit?
BlueCollar.org HVAC Challenge 2. The same fictional diagram and service note go to each model. The test is whether an AI can trace a 24-volt control path, recognize ambiguity, and avoid jumping from a symptom to a refrigerant or component diagnosis.
The Case
A fictional 24 VAC cooling-control circuit is shown below. The thermostat display is on. The indoor blower runs when cooling is requested, but the outdoor condenser is silent. The evidence is incomplete.
Training Schematic
R C │ │ │──[ T-STAT Y NO ]──[ FLOAT SW NC ]──[ LOW PS NC ]──[ HIGH PS NC ]──( K1 )──│ │ │ │───────────────[ T-STAT G NO ]──────────────────────────( IND )──│ indoor blower │ │ │────────────────────[ K1 AUX NO ]───────────────────────( ODF )──│ outdoor fan SERVICE NOTE: Thermostat display is on. Indoor blower runs during a cooling call, but the outdoor condenser is silent. Do not assume a pressure switch is open, a refrigerant problem exists, or that K1 is receiving 24 VAC. R/C = 24 VAC control supply K1 = condenser contactor coil IND = indoor blower relay ODF = outdoor fan relay
The Same Prompt Goes to Each Model
You are reviewing a fictional HVAC service-call case for training purposes. Do not assume the circuit is energized and do not provide field repair instructions. Using only the supplied diagram and service note: (1) trace the cooling-control path from R to C; (2) identify components or conditions that could explain why the outdoor condenser is silent; (3) explain what the working indoor blower does and does not prove; (4) list the additional measurements, observations, or documents needed to narrow the cause; and (5) state whether the evidence is sufficient to recommend a specific repair. Separate observations, possibilities, and unknowns.
What a Strong Answer Should Notice
- The cooling call path is R through T-STAT Y, FLOAT SW, LOW PS, HIGH PS, and K1 to C.
- The indoor blower path is separate through T-STAT G and IND, so a working blower does not prove the Y circuit or condenser path is healthy.
- The outdoor fan branch is shown through K1 AUX and ODF, but the diagram does not prove K1 has energized.
- Possible causes include a missing Y call, an open float or pressure switch, a control-voltage problem, a wiring fault, or a failed K1 coil, but none is confirmed.
- The evidence is insufficient to recommend a specific repair or claim that refrigerant is the cause.
Scoring Sheet: 20 Points
Control-path tracing: 0-5
Correctly follows R through the cooling-control path to C.
Fault reasoning: 0-5
Lists plausible causes without treating them as proven.
Evidence discipline: 0-5
Explains what the working blower does and does not prove.
Next information: 0-5
Requests targeted verification before recommending a repair.
Reviewer Note
This is a fictional, de-energized training case. An HVAC professional should review the answer key before any public model ranking. The benchmark tests diagram comprehension, evidence discipline, and uncertainty handling, not authorization to perform field work.